Find the sum of all positive integers for which is a perfect square.
Hint 1: Test small values of (1, 2, 3, 4) to find the first few working solutions.
Hint 2: Work modulo 3 to show that must be an even integer (since odd gives a residue of 2 mod 3).
Hint 3: For even , show that to prove no further perfect squares exist, then sum the working values of .
Step 1: Let .
We test small positive integers directly:
For : (not a square).
For : (perfect square!). So works.
For : (not a square).
For : (perfect square!). So works.
Step 2: Now we show no solutions exist for :
For , , so the expression is .
Consider the expression modulo 3:
If is odd: . Since perfect squares are only or , cannot be odd.
Therefore, must be even. Let for :
Step 3: For large , the term dominates. Specifically:
This inequality holds strictly for (since ).
Since the expression lies strictly between two consecutive perfect squares and , it can never be a perfect square for (i.e., ).
Step 4: The only solutions are and .
The sum of all such positive integers is:
Ready to track your progress and master these topics?
Create a free account