Prove that there exists a positive constant such that the following statement is true:
Consider an integer , and a set of points in the plane such that the distance between any two different points in is at least . It follows that there is a line separating such that the distance from any point of to is at least .
(A line separates a set of points if some segment joining two points in crosses .)
Such a constant exists, achieving separation distance .
Such a constant exists, achieving separation distance .
Such a constant exists, achieving separation distance .
Such a constant exists, achieving separation distance .
Hint 1: Project the points onto a line in direction . A separating line perpendicular to corresponds to a gap in the projection.
Hint 2: Use the minimum distance condition: the packing density in any strip of width is . This limits how many projections can cluster together.
Hint 3: Average over random directions . Show that for , the expected number of 'blocked' gaps is less than , so some gap of width exists.
Step 1 (Strategy): We show that among all lines in a suitable family, at least one separates while being far from all points. Consider lines perpendicular to a fixed direction.
Step 2 (Project onto a line): Choose a direction and project all points of onto the line in direction . Let be the projections.
Step 3 (Gaps between projections): We need a gap for some with (so the perpendicular line in this gap separates ). By the minimum distance condition, the points are spread out.
Step 4 (Counting close pairs): For a random direction , the expected number of pairs with can be bounded using the minimum distance condition. Since for all pairs, the projections satisfy: at most points can have projections within any interval of width (packing argument in strips of width ).
Step 5 (Conclusion): Choosing for a suitable constant , and averaging over directions , one finds a direction and a gap of width . The perpendicular bisector at this gap gives the desired line .
Ready to track your progress and master these topics?
Create a free account