Back to Mathematical Olympiad
Difficulty: 10/102015 IMO 2015 (Q6)

The sequence of integers satisfies the following conditions:

(i) for all ;

(ii) for all .

Prove that there exist two positive integers and such that

for all integers .

Options:

  • A.

    There exist and such that for all .

  • B.

    There exist and such that for all .

  • C.

    There exist and such that for all .

  • There exist and such that for all .

Guide / Hint

Hint 1: The condition means the function is injective. Think of the values as 'labels' — each label is used at most once.

Hint 2: For each integer , at most one index satisfies . Among , how many are 'used'? This forces to be nearly periodic.

Hint 3: Show that eventually takes each value in with bounded gaps. Choose appropriately and bound the partial sum deviation using the pigeonhole principle.

Solution

Step 1 (Reformulation): Condition (ii) says the map is injective. Since , the values for form an infinite subset of with no repeats. Consider the "carrier lines" ; each has at most one element by (ii). So for each , at most one index satisfies .

Step 2 (Density argument): Among the integers , the values with cover at most of them (and exactly those with and , i.e., ). For large , among , most are "used" by close to .

Step 3 (Key insight): The function must eventually settle into a near-constant pattern. Specifically, for large , takes each value in roughly equally often among consecutive blocks (by the pigeonhole principle applied to the injective condition). The "average" value of over long blocks approaches some integer .

Step 4 (Bounding partial sums): Choose as the value most frequently taken by (or more precisely, the value that minimizes the drift). The injectivity of ensures that the partial sums cannot drift by more than the range of squared, since each "carrier" is used at most once. The maximum deviation is bounded by .

Ready to track your progress and master these topics?

Create a free account